Veteran’s suicidal past wasn’t known when police put him in cell, inquiry hears



Military police would have watched an Afghanistan war veteran around-the-clock while he was locked up in a cell had they been aware of his suicidal history, a provincial inquiry into a corporal’s death was told Tuesday.

Sergeant Matthew Parkin, one of three military police officers who dealt with Corporal Shaun Collins on March 9, 2011, acknowledged in testimony Tuesday that they would not have placed the young soldier in a darkened cell without supervision if they had known he tried to take his life several times before. The military’s security information database would have turned up those suicide attempts, but the corporal’s name was misspelled when it was entered – one of several custody safeguards that failed at the police guardhouse at the Edmonton base.

Cpl. Collins, 27, had been arrested that night for allegedly driving drunk and refusing to provide a breath sample. While the police officers were in a nearby room finishing paperwork, he hanged himself with a noose fashioned from his combat shirt and attached to the bars of the cell door. He died in a hospital two days later.

His suicide is part of a mounting toll. A continuing Globe and Mail has revealed that at least 62 soldiers and veterans have taken their lives after serving on the Afghanistan mission.

The provincial fatality inquiry into Cpl. Collins’s death was ordered by the Alberta Justice Minister and offers a rare glimpse inside the military, which conducts its own death investigations, but always behind closed doors.

Cpl. Collins appeared to be getting better in 2011, his mental-health doctors testified Tuesday, at the second day of a four-day inquiry. In December, 2010, he turned to a psychologist outside of the military system because he worried seeking help within would harm his career.

A friend had recommended trauma specialist Keli Furman to him. He was extremely distressed, Dr. Furman recalled.

She said he was affected by the deaths of fellow soldiers in Afghanistan and atrocities he had witnessed there. He told her he felt harassed and abused by one of his supervisors. He was also struggling to cope with his sister’s murder and a deadly vehicle accident involving his friends in Alberta.

He struggled with guilt, flashbacks and drinking. He had become scared of driving, going to restaurants and walking into Wal-Mart.

“He was one of the most severe cases of PTSD that I had seen in my career,” Dr. Furman testified. “There was clear evidence that he had been exposed to horrific events.”

After their first meeting, Dr. Furman saw Cpl. Collins for two-hour sessions twice a week. She received approval from the Canadian Forces to treat him. Military members are not covered by provincial health-care systems.

The young soldier wanted to get better, Dr. Furman said. He reduced his drinking and avoided parties and a friend’s engagement bash, because he didn’t want to be tempted. However, he declined alcohol treatment, saying he could quit on his own.

Dr. Furman worked with him to control his temper and ground him in reality. Military psychiatrist Catherine Phillips also saw Cpl. Collins, talking with him and monitoring his medication. He was taking an anti-depressant, sleeping pills and anti-psychotic medication to stabilize his mood.

Cpl. Collins met with Dr. Furman the day before he hanged himself. She saw no signs then that he was a suicide risk. Instead, he was excited about his future and about getting married. He recently got a cat and was enjoying his woodworking job in the military.

He was slated to be transferred to the Joint Personnel Support Unit. Both he and his psychologist didn’t know much about the unit created in 2008 to help ill and wounded soldiers heal. He said he hoped to take a soapstone-carving class at the JPSU, to keep seeing Dr. Furman and remain in his woodworking job at the Edmonton base.

“He knew he had a long way to go, but he was highly motivated to recover,” Dr. Furman told the inquiry.

It appears Cpl. Collins reported to the JPSU on the morning of March 9, 2011. He later went drinking at a bar on base, ignored a bartender’s urging that he not drive away in his black SUV and then was stopped by the military police and arrested.

He smelled of alcohol, Sgt. Parkin, then a corporal, testified. He was aggressive and resisted arrest. When he was told he would be detained, Cpl. Collins got more agitated. He yelled at Sgt. Parkin and another corporal not to call him a detainee. That was a loaded word in Afghanistan.

Less than two and half hours later, Cpl. Collins was found hanged in his cell. The military police guardhouse’s video-monitoring system wasn’t working and its cell doors posed a hanging hazard, the inquiry has heard. At the time, the military cells did not meet Canadian correctional standards.

Also on The Globe and Mail



Inside The Globe investigation on suicide rates of Canadian vets in Afghanistan
(The Globe and Mail)

Courtesy: The Globe And Mail

7 thoughts on “Veteran’s suicidal past wasn’t known when police put him in cell, inquiry hears

  1. When is the military going to give up the idea that mind-altering drugs, drugs that carry warnings about increased suicidality, are helpful to people suffering trauma? These medications, primarily SSRI antidepressants in combination with so-called antipsychotics, have increased the rate of suicide dramatically. Meanwhile, in the US and Canada, military brass wring their hands and search for the reason that suicides among troops have skyrocketed relative to past, unmedicated generations. They simply refuse to consider the obvious. At least in the US the Senate held hearings about it. No such luck in Canada.

  2. The first thing to do is to stop sending our soliders to participate in American military adventures. Our soldiers should never have been sent to Afghanistan. This action, unfortunately, is too late for the soldiers already sent abroad and who have returned home physically and/or mentally wounded. Each wounded soldier must be cared for, for the rest of his/her life, if necessary. As a country, it’s the least we can do for our young people who may have survived these wars, but are too broken to function when they return home.

  3. Chris Welcome to “Club Ed”… Interesting that the video monitoring was not working… Are you kidding me people. We all know what goes on in the Armed Forces… they aren’t trained like civilians and really when you have people categorized merely as federal property (nothing more)… What do you think happens. Perhaps authorities who really want to shed light on the needless death peel back some layers (like an onion) they will most like notice the camera’s were working a day before, and even day(s) (perhaps to validate their story) later… Perhaps staff saw yet just another drunk tank occupant and decided to resume their course of daily / evening activities i.e. watch t.v., sleep, chit chat in the lounge…. hmmm. I’m not justifying the actions of the member who took his life, there is a little bit of ownership and accountability for one’s own behaviour, but when someone is so delusional of their own plight, then we as “humans” need to recognize that… and “Man up”.

  4. “He had become scared of driving, going to restaurants and walking into Wal-Mart.”

    … yet.

    “He later went drinking at a bar on base, ignored a bartender’s urging that he not drive away in his black SUV”

  5. ‘She received approval from the Canadian Forces to treat him. Military members are not covered by provincial health-care systems.’ Hello? What is wrong with our society? not covered by provincial health care? what about federal? This is so tragic.

  6. There is no drug for PTSD.

    The problem here is, as human beings, people attack those who are “weak” or perceived as so, so people don’t like to hear about PTSD.

    Problem is – the Charter of Rights is the LAW OF THE LAND and so are the Human Rights Codes.

    Governments and people MUST FOLLOW THEM.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *